Pennywick Mysteries

A cozy mystery in five clues.

Every day, something goes missing in the little seaside town of Pennywick. Read the case, study the suspects, and reveal clues one at a time. Name the culprit early for more points, but you only get one accusation.

Coming November 2

Case no. 1

The Prize Pie

At the Pennywick summer fair, Mrs. Thimble’s blackberry pie was cooling on the windowsill of the judging tent. When the judges came to taste it, the pie was gone, and the window was wide open.

Who did it?

How to solve a case

  1. Read the case

    Each morning brings a new mystery and four suspects, each with a few facts on their card.

  2. Reveal the clues

    Start with one clue and uncover up to five. Rule out suspects as the clues let you.

  3. Make your accusation

    You get one guess. The fewer clues you needed, the higher your score. Then share your result, spoiler-free.

Accuse after 1 clue: 5 points2 clues: 43 clues: 34 clues: 25 clues: 1

Meet the villagers

Twenty-four familiar faces turn up as suspects, and every one of them is guilty at least once. Nobody in Pennywick is a real villain. There’s always a sweet reason behind the mystery.

Mrs. HollisBaker
Mr. PennReporter
Rosa ValeFlorist
Colonel BarnabyClock keeper
Nell BrightNight guard
Captain MossSea captain
Grace KimCafé owner
Dr. OkaforVillage vet

Never miss a case

Today’s case is always free. Missed a day? Past cases will live in the Culprit Corner, our case archive, as part of Plus.

The Culprit Corner

The full case archive is coming soon.

Get notified

Questions

Is it free?

Yes. Today’s case is free for everyone, every day.

Is it a murder mystery?

No. Pennywick is a cozy town. Mysteries are about missing pies, moved wreaths, and secret kindnesses, so they’re friendly for all ages.

How long does a case take?

Most cases take two to five minutes.

Do I need to download anything?

No. It plays right in your browser on phones, tablets, and computers.

What if I accuse the wrong person?

The case closes and you’ll see the full explanation of how the clues pointed to the culprit. There’s a new case tomorrow!